Unique: Who to pull with the ticket

I need help with who to select:

Who do I have to?:

1. meli

2. king

3. guila

4. drake

5. Tristan, tioreh, slater, Gil, Dreyfus (+ Son and Grandson), Hendrickson, bug.

Given this who would be the best choice for me to pick between:

1. Elaine

2. Mannie

3. Diane

4. Jericho