Picking Villagers

Do you personally prioritize a villager's appearance or their traits? I designed my rough draft in my head making sure I had at least one of each personality type (a mix of different hobbies too), but then I went through and made a list of my favorite villagers based on species (picked my favorite of each). I realized that there were some differences and now I am conflicted with who I may want in the end. For example, Sherb is my favorite lazy villager, but not my favorite goat villager. Hard to decide when they make so many of them adorable.

Example: