Neutrogena Mineral SPF - is there a skin tint it works with??

Question in title, basically. I (accidentally) bought the Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Mineral SPF instead of my usual Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Face Serum cause the box looked similar and I didn't read close enough. The Face Serum stuff worked great, absorbed in well, played well with my skin tint, no issues.

The mineral is utter trash for me. White as hell when it goes on, feels weirdly tacky and sticky even hours later, and every skin tint I have, it breaks down/pills. I've tried Fenty Eaze Drops, NARS Tinted Moisturizer and L'Oreal True Match Nude Serum Tint. I really don't want to just throw out an almost full bottle of SPF but I'm not a fan of wearing the white casted stuff without something else on it because I looked like I've got the consumption.