I ran a real CTR experiment across ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini & Grok… results are split 🤯

I’m trying to optimize titles for SEO (AI tools niche), so I tested something interesting:

👉 Same query
👉 Same data (impressions)
👉 Asked 4 AI models to rate CTR

🧪 The Test

Option 1
“Grok Video Generation & Aurora Voice (April 2026): Who Has Access?”

Option 2
“Grok Voice Mode Is Available Now — Here’s How to Turn It On”

📊 Search Impressions (24h sample)

• “grok voice mode availability 2026”
• “does grok have video generation april 2026”
• “grok voice feature availability”

(mix of availability + feature intent)

🤖 AI Results

• Grok → Option 1 (9/10)
• ChatGPT → Option 2 (9.6/10)
• Gemini → Option 1 (9/10)
• Claude → Option 2 (8.5/10)

👉 So it’s literally 2 vs 2

🧠 My Observation

• Option 1 = better for feature-based queries (video, specs)
• Option 2 = better for action/intent queries (“how to enable”, “available now”)

❓ Where I’m stuck

Should CTR be optimized for:
👉 search intent match (Option 2)
OR
👉 feature-rich curiosity hook (Option 1)

Would love real opinions from people doing SEO / content — what would YOU pick and why?