Cheap airport hotel or discounted downtown 5 star?

I'm going to be staying overnight, arriving at 8pm and leaving the next day at 12:30pm.

Option 1 - Abercorn hotel for $306 CAD
Option 2 - Hyatt Vancouver Downtown Alberni for $344 CAD (includes free breakfast)

My gut tells me it's better to save money and suck it up at a not great hotel for ~12 hours but some of the reviews are making me think it's worth some extra money and time to stay in a nice room.