What guitar equipment and settings to use for One Day

So i want to achieve the most authentic sound for One Day (Im playing Will's part), i have a tele and i use the neck pickup although if u think i should be using one of the other pickups than please let me know. I use a positive grid spark amp where i control all the settings and pedals in an app so i can basically use anything, i tried countless combinations but it just doesnt sound the same (i dont need exactly the same just as close as possible). Also please dont send me equipboards that doesnt help. Thank you.