Is this type of content monetizable, or do they just spam?

I'm certain you guys have seen those YouTube shorts where it's a clip from a movie or a TV show, but faintly, there is an AI-voiced narration of what's going on in the background, not loud enough for you to hear, but it is technically there, and it also has subtitles.

These channels post hundreds of these clips with the same technique. Since the background music royalty method is patched, is this some sort of new method that technically makes it a transformative YT Short, or is it just plain old spam uploading?