Memory Loss as a world feature - Am I making things too hard for myself?

Need Advice: Worldbuilding

I'm a relatively experienced DM preparing a campaign for experienced players, some who are fellow DMs, and we have our session 0 coming up in a couple of weeks. My narrative setup that I will introduce during the session is, in summary, roughly as follows:

The campaign surrounds a world of increasing fey influence, which over the course of the last two centuries has driven civilization out of their towns and villages and into a few large isolated cities, leaving the outer areas (now the 'Wildlands') unkempt and dangerous.

Access to the wildlands is not normally available for regular citizens, and any adventure will be done under contract of a more powerful party. Whether that's a government, a business, or a criminal faction. These are all facilitated by a legal party that, as part of these contracts, tends to use memory erasure to remove details about the contract and its activities in case of a breach of contract, or upon completion if the activities part of a contract are especially sensitive. It's like the magical version of a hefty NDA, and whoever undergoes this will be compensated for this monetarily.

This is all part of the setting, which the players will be made familiar with at session 0. I will motivate them to make characters that, despite these memory erasure clauses, are eager enough to agree with these types of contracts. "They know what they signed up for". Once I have their character details I can prepare prologue sessions that surround their motivations and introduce the contracts they individually signed to enter the wildlands.

After this prologue, stating with 'chapter 1', we actually shift forwards in time. The campaign isn't about playing out these contracts in the wildlands, it's about the players finding out they breached them and signed away their memories of the events. The players find themselves imprisoned, post memory-erasure. They know they signed the contract, signed up for memory erasure in case of breach, and somewhere along the way must have breached it. What happened in between during their expedition into the wildlands remains unknown, and either getting their memories back or finding a way back into the wildlands to retrace their steps will be a core story feature.

Now, the main question is, am I making things really hard for myself with this hook? It probably means taking some agency away from players by deciding on a series of events their characters participated in. Stuff that, in the present, neither the player or character knows about. This might be challenging to properly execute in a satisfying way, and runs the risk of writing events or actions the character undertook during that time that end up not fitting the player's view of said character.

These are worries I have going into session 0, and if there is some better way to approach this hook (or something with similar effect) I'd love to have some second thoughts. I think it's a very strong hook as long as the players are aware of it when they make their characters, and I'd like to make it work. But if your conclusion is something like 'under no circumstance try this, just write something else', I'd be open to that as well. I have time to adjust.

Posted Apr 21, 2026, 9:45 AM UTC

715

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 15 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.