Help! Stuck between 30-year and 20-year fixed options.
Hello! Me and my partner have two pretty strong options (or at least we think so) on the table for financing our first home. Need to decide later today due to closing timeline. Opinions welcome!
Purchase price = $465K
Location = Albany NY area
House = good inspection; no urgent issues, but we would love to modernize and upgrade certain things.
Two mortgage options are outlined further below. One is a 30-year conventional at 6.000%. The other is a 20-year conventional at 5.625%.
We are viewing option 1 as being the flexible, “keep more cash on hand for upgrades and investment accounts” play.
Option 2 we are viewing as the more aggressive, lower-interest, faster-equity-building option. We would still maintain a healthy cash buffer (even with 25% down) in this scenario, but things would definitely be tighter for doing upgrades/house projects.
Option 1: 30-year conventional at 6.000%
- Down payment: 20%
- Monthly payment (including tax and insurance): roughly $2,950
Option 2: 20-year conventional at 5.625%
- Down payment: 25%
- Monthly payment: roughly $3,200
What would you guys do?? My lizard brain says “lower interest GOOD” buuut I’m also wondering if I might regret having less flexibility / maybe that extra down payment money could be better spent or invested elsewhere.
Thanks!
Posted Apr 23, 2026, 12:52 PM UTC