Disclaimer - I am an employee and make my own cookies. Reviews are based on how we test and sell them in store.

Kentucky butter cake 🧈 1/10 - I have never liked this cookie, from the first time I tried it before I worked here I have hated it. It is basically butter in cookie form, not like the real dessert that is rich with vanilla and yellow cake flavors. It tastes like what stereotypical depression feels like, sad and heavy. 

Churro 🌀 7/10 - lots of cinnamon sugar flavor! Very simple cinnamon base cookie with a cinnamon sugar buttercream, but the base cookie is wildly better than the standard snickerdoodle. The snickerdoodle at Crumbl have a weird, rancid flavor while this is very warm and rich with cinnamon. The cinnamon sugar dusting on top is a nice touch. Wish it had more crunch to it like a real churro has. Maybe some churro pieces on top!

White chocolate raspberry cheesecake 🤍9/10 - oh I knew I’d love this!! It has the Andros premade jam which is way better than housemade, and a white drop cream cheese frosting, which is new! It’s a bit creamier than normal, but sweeter with the tang of cream cheese. There’s surprisingly no butter in this frosting! The base cookie is the same as cookies and cream, just slightly smaller in size. There’s lots of jam on top, and the sweetness of that really pairs well with the frosting and rich cocoa cookie. Extra Oreo pieces on top add some nice texture. Overall this is a really well balanced cookie and it definitely knocks the regular raspberry cheesecake out of the park.

Cookie butter tres leches 🍪 8.9/10 - what? Me? Liking a tres leches from Crumbl?? YES. I’ve loved this one from the beginning because it is packed full of flavor AND IT’S BISCOFF. Although I’m not a fan of the goopy cake, it’s better than the usual dry crumbl cake, and this cake is full of spices. A nice layer of biscoff, then whipped cream which is refreshing but pretty boring and lacks flavor. Imagine if it was a Biscoff whipped cream! More Biscoff cookies and more Biscoff on top (I added more underneath the cookies in my picture) makes this a sucker punch in the face of Biscoff, and I wouldn’t want it any other way. Again, I’m not a fan of tres leches from Crumbl, but this one is actually flavorful and worth the extra charge. 

Also thought I’d share some of the blue sugars I frosted. Not my best work by any means because the frostings weren’t combining well, but they’re so pretty!! 

Cat tax 🐱- Milo and Peanut

Review Week 4/27/2026