Finished the show- what next?

Just finished the animated show, and I absolutely loved it. I plan to buy the books next time I'm in a bookstore, and consume copious amounts of fanfiction. But in the meantime, what can I watch that has the same vibes (plotty and gay)? I know Grandmaster of Diabolism is the popular next choice, but I, unfortunately, require an English dub. My brain absolutely hates subbed shows.

Any recommendations are welcome!