What’s my best FNC value?

I live in Tampa, FL and have 1 Hilton free night certificate plus 200k points. I’m planning a 3-night, 4-day trip and want to maximize my time without spending most of it traveling. I’ve already stayed at WA Cabo and Cancun and it was incredible

I’m deciding between:

Zemi Beach House, Anguilla
Waldorf Astoria Costa Rica
Hilton Aruba Beach & Casino

I know Zemi and the Waldorf are a higher tier than the Hilton in Aruba, but I’m wondering if they’re actually worth the extra travel hassle for such a short trip.

Would really appreciate any insight—especially from anyone who’s stayed at these properties.