Can’t get EVH / Slash tones in GarageBand (JS32 + interface)

I’m using a Jackson JS32 into an audio interface with GarageBand on Mac, and I’m trying to get tones for Eruption, Beat It solo, and November Rain solo. I can play them well, but the tone just sounds off no matter what I do

I’ve already tried a bunch of amps and pedals in GarageBand and now I’m just confused with too many options

Can someone guide me on which amp and cab to use, what basic settings I should start with, and if there are any specific pedals or mic settings that actually work for these tones? 

also is GarageBand the problem here or could it be my JS32