Advice for second toy after using too soft of one (surii, very soft designed more for female)

Amazing last night we finally tried pegging after months of curiosity! I loved it.
We were spontaneous and used what was on hand-- a scarf and very soft silicone one called surii, 6.1 inches long and about 1 inch diameter
I took it well but it was so floppy it wasn't great to insert and I think something firmer would be better. The size was fine and I'm very skinny but think I could handle a bit longer and or thicker too. I would love one that hits my prostate better too.
Does anyone have any recommendations or suggestions as to what to get next ? I'm so excited and grateful for my partner