2 shotguns

I currently don’t own any shotguns after selling my old pump, and I’d like to end up with two eventually: one for home defense and one for hunting/clays.

I’m trying to stay as budget-friendly as possible without buying junk, and right now I keep coming back to the Beretta A300 line or the Stoeger M3000.

Would you guys buy two versions of the same shotgun with different barrel lengths/configurations, or would you go with two completely different guns?

I’m assuming the A300 Ultima Patrol is too short to really be ideal for hunting or clays.