My Theory On Guts and Casca
[HEAVY SPOILERS AHEAD BOTH FOR LATEST
CHAPTERS ASWELL AS MANY OLDER CHAPTERS]
Ever since Casca was "brought back" this thought had never left my brain, that if back in after Conviction, Guts didnt get possessed and try to assault Casca, she could atleast interact with him up until the "old days" were mentioned, like with Jeudeu, or others.
Now that i think of it it might be 3rd greatest tragedy in Guts's life, besides his woman being stripped of her dignity right infront of him and losing her mind, beside his and her child being corrupted into becoming demon by Griffith, now he will have to live with a fact that one time of weakness, caused Casca to view Guts just like she views terrible monsters that raped and abused her. Atleast for a time i hope before Casca finds a way to cope with everything.
We see hints of it In Falconia, hypnotized by presumably Sonia, Casca thinks about Guts, and not the Golden Age Guts, but full berserker armor Guts. And she doesnt fall into immediate panic attack as before instead she tries to fight the hypnosis and fights off guards at Griffits castle.
Could this be a hint that eventually Casca will accept what happened, and finally stop being terrified of Guts? I think yea, but i still want to hear your opinions on the matter. Wheter we like it kr not, Skull Knights warnings are no joke so we have to count that in aswell...
Posted May 12, 2026, 6:16 AM UTC