My first composition - a piano waltz. Thoughts on the engraving, form, and overall coherence?
Hello,
I'm an amateur interested in all aspects of music, recently I've been trying my hand at composition. After scrapping a bunch of drafts I've tried to go for something simple and relatively short. My main goals are coherence and clear form (AB).
~3 minutes; score in PDF and Musescore linked below.
What I'd most like feedback on:
- Engraving: I've been really careful to make it right - happy to hear what can be improved, especially the 6/8 section looks a little bit ugly
- Overall coherence and form
- Specifics - some posts on this sub receive wonderfully specific feedback like 'replace G with B in the LH in m. 4 to improve voice leading' - this kind of input is also greatly appreciated
Thank you!
Posted May 12, 2026, 8:13 AM UTC
09