I wanna see what you guys think, cause most people get this wrong. Read for my explanation before answering please. People always ask “who is the best fighter among the Batmen?”

Bale gets chronically underrated in terms of abilities, but I would say he is the best fighter after Keaton out of all the live action Batmen movies (The Flash movie does count). 

Bale fights often 8-12 guys at the same time, with league of shadows training in Rises, and beats all of them within 20 seconds. Meanwhile Batfleck needs for lesser trained 22 fighters in the warehouse around 5 minutes. Do the math who is more effective.

The best of all the live action fighters among Batmen is Keaton. No 2 year prep time like Batfleck he takes down Kryptonian giant Nam-ek (he does but it’s still a huge feat) and the fight in the missle silo is as cool as the warehouse fight, but much quicker and efficient. He is also the most proficient with gadgets especially batarangs as he also shows in The Flash.

But again… people will yell and cry and say Battinson and Batfleck are better fighters. No, you like their fights better. That’s a different question.

People confuse “do I like the action scenes” with “is he a good fighter”.   
Bale has arguably the worst fight scenes in a choreography standpoint, but result wise he is the most efficient. He rarely gets hit (except from Bane), almost every punch is a one hit KO to the opponent, so he also arguably punches the strongest. Meanwhile Affleck gets stabbed, shot and Battinson gets punched in the face sometimes 2-3 times in a row with no guard work. Objectively they are worse fighters.

If I would have to rank them in terms of who has cooler fight scenes, of course Batfleck would probably be no 1 (even tho I still think the missle silo fight from Keaton is up there, just a lil short), but that’s not the question. 

Meet the two best fighters among the live action Batmen