I tried my hand at a full, thought-through Tier List. Since CC in particular is so matchup dependant and a lot of the convicts fluctuates in their overall power.

This list is based on the strongest version of all the convicts.

I might make one later with different versions of the convicts.

S+

\- No one else can compare to these 2. We even have VI admit that they're on another level.

S

\- Definite #3 and #4. I see VI push Pete snd EC further than, and beat FM more often than not.

A+

\- GIAB consistently loses to the ones above by being out-done in pure bs. He hard stat checks everyone below. Karmic Blade is a really hard one to rank. I honestly don't think anyone below can beat full gear R1 KB. Perhaps ICT and Monkey See due to their respective hax.

A

\- This is the most non-linear tier imo. ICT is only at the top since I believe he would hypnotize and one-shot anyone below, ÷ Abyss whom I simply think he stat checks. Without his hypnosis he should be right above / interchangable with Tempest. Tomahawk and Beatdown are interchangable. I placed Monkey See below Abyss cause against such an opponent he is bound to fuck up due to his overconfidence imo. I think LH is at least narratively comparable to Tempest, but I do actually have a theory that he is stronger.

B+

\- Is only a slight step below A tier. Scourge and Samoan are as close as can be. I put Karmic Blade here based on the facts that I: a) doesn't think he reliably gets the thumbs up in time, b) expect the opponent to just tank or evade, against anyone above him. Rawdog is close, but consistently loses against anyone above him, with a possible exception of Abyss. He stat checks anyone below.

B

\- These 3 are somewhat close. Arm Thief  gets a succesful hold or lock on Never-Ending and Firecracker more often than not. Firecracker being below Never-Ending mostly connects to his own statement.

C+

\- These guys are a cut above the guys in C and are somewhat interchangable.

C

\- Iron Turtle and Spider Bite are the weakest actual fighters, or Holy Scythe who has lethal offensive power snd decent speed.

D+

\- I believe Geared-Up loses consistently to anyone above him, and stat checks everyone below.

D

\- Either really mediocre fighters or too gimmicky to be any higher. AD has no real feats, but I hope a side story or character profile would give some insights to his overall capabilites.