r/dirtypenpals•
Jace_1997

[M4F] Maybe your 'gay' best friend is not THAT gay after all... [Discord, slow burn, detailed]

NSFW RP - Ongoing

We first met when you moved to the new city and came to respond to my ad for a roommate. I was immediately smitten with you. You had the perfect body, your eyes were hypnotic, and your plump lips were ideal for sucking cock. Unfortunately though, you had a boyfriend and you were very loyal to him. So I couldn't exactly make any moves. But on that first meeting, you slipped and said that you had always wanted a gay best friend. Before I knew it, I was telling you that I was gay.

As I had wanted, you moved in, and we soon became close friends. Your boyfriend was mostly okay with our friendship, at least in the beginning. Like a normal guy, he was suspicious, but you defended me. When you asked why I didn't have a boyfriend, I made up a sob story about getting my heart broken and not being ready for another relationship yet. Little by little I got closer to you. You got comfortable with casual touches, like holding my hand, snuggling with me on the couch on those rare days when your boyfriend had not come over. Sometimes we went shopping or to the movies when there was a girly movie that he didn't want to watch.

During these times, I had also started to poison your mind against your boyfriend. It was not obvious. Every time you complained against him, I took your side and said how right you were. I made subtle remarks every time he screwed up. On the other hand, I also manipulated him and told him to do the exact same things you did not like. He naively trusted me. You still loved him. You had been a couple for many years, after all. But I felt like at some level of that perfect relationship, a crack had started to appear.

One day he really screwed up. You wanted to go on a trip- a week away from your stressful life, but your boyfriend had just taken a big project on at work and didn't think he should go. The fight you had was the worst one yet. I played both sides. I told him that he should focus on his career and help save money for your future. And I told you that he should have made you more of a priority. And then you decided that I should be the one to go with you on that trip. Just a week away between two best friends. Nothing weird, right? Your boyfriend reluctantly agreed. But I knew that this would be the best opportunity if I wanted to make you cheat on him and claim you as my own. This was the perfect time for us to 'discover' that I might not be gay after all...

~

Hi beautiful people,

Thanks for reading my prompt. It's a very simple one. The tl;dr version is: Your 'gay' best friend, who is not really gay, had been manipulating and gaslighting both you and your boyfriend. Eventually we will be going on a trip together, one you had arranged for you and your boyfriend, we will get even more intimate and I will 'discover' that I'm not exactly gay. Every girl has a secret fantasy that she can turn a handsome gay man straight, right?

The plot is open. We can make whatever changes you want. We don't need to be roommates, the boyfriend can hate me, or any other change you can think of. We'll discuss and make the story our own. But I'd like it to be a slow burn, hopefully medium to long term roleplay, full of fun build up, whether romantic or depraved or plain silly, and a lot of sexual tension, and later on, sex.

For your character, I ideally prefer a faceclaim or at least a reference. I know it's not for everyone. So if you are completely against that, we can discuss it.

Please be at least semi-literate. I'm not interested in single line replies or sexting. Other information about my writing style are given below.

~

Kinks- cheating, cuckolding, dub-con (some non-con might be okay), manipulation, seduction, degradation, misogyny, gaslighting, emotional abuse, humiliation, groping, light BDSM (bondage, blindfold, spanking, choking, toys), oral, rough sex, public/risky sex, unsafe sex, threat of pregnancy (NOT actual pregnancy), cock/breast/pussy worship, maledom, submissive female, outfit control, sweat, spit, alcohol and drugs, reference pics etc. I should point out that all these are optional and we can go with whatever you are comfortable with.

Limits- femdom, bestiality, toilet stuff, excessive violence, and breeding (unsafe sex and threat of pregnancy are fine).

Writing style- I'm an experienced roleplayer, doing this for about 11 years now. I use first and second person exclusively, usually in past tense. I prefer Discord by far, since it's easier to manage and it lets me save chats to read later. so people using it will get preference. You can usually expect at least a few exchanges a day. I absolutely detest low effort, single line replies.

My ideal size is between 2-4 small paragraphs, up to one Discord message in length, but it's negotiable. I have done a lot longer replies too. I also love discussing stuff in OOC. Oh and I appreciate occasional reference pics, especially when choosing outfits, but they're not an absolute necessity.

~

If you like my prompt, please send me a detailed chat (thanks for getting rid of the wonderful DM system and leaving us saddled with a chat that doesn't work half the time, Reddit) with your ideas of your character, and your thoughts about the prompt, especially if you have any thoughts on how you'd like the story to go. I'd appreciate a list of kinks and limits as well.

This prompt will be open as long as the post is up. All my previous prompts are open as well.

Posted May 13, 2026, 6:27 PM UTC

30
Loading comments…