[712]The Veil Between Worlds - Opening Paragraphs

The start of my epic fantasy novel. Obviously it is important that people feel compelled to read past the first sentence, paragraph, page, etc. Hopefully there is also some kind of thread that people want to know the conclusion of. Please let me know whether it meets these criteria. Be as harsh and nit-picky as you like; I want to improve.

-------

Astred had imagined that leaving would feel grander.

He had imagined this moment a hundred times in the quiet hours of the scriptorium; striding out with purpose, the wind catching his robe heroically, the monks watching, forced to acknowledge his conviction in action. Instead, no one had come to see him off, and the only thing catching his robe was a bramble. So Astred sheepishly hustled through the gate with his head down, unsure if the cough he heard behind him was a monk surprised to see him leave, or just someone about their daily chores.

His makeshift shield; a rectangular slab of old fence pickets, lashed together with twine and stubborn optimism; rattled on his back like a bundle of kindling. The wooden cudgel he carried was the closest thing he could find to a proper mace. These were the implements that a world faring cleric needed; or at least this was implied by the illustrations in the monastery's library books.

He paused to adjust his coarse brown robe, which was collecting burrs at a concerning rate. His breath fogged in the morning air as he risked a glance down into the valley. He knew there had to be a village somewhere down there; every monk understood that the monastery’s trade had to pass through some kind of foothill settlement; but he had never seen it himself. The idea of it had always filled his imagination with warmth: friendly faces, bustling paths, hearthfire, real conversation. A place where life happened out in the open instead of behind stone walls.

The nearest village lay below.

Perfectly ordinary.

Perfectly full of possibility.

Surely full of people in dire need of Astred's service.

He turned back toward the monastery perched near the summit. Its pale stone walls looked calm, solemn, unchanged. No one stood watching. No one had tried to stop him; of course monks were not prisoners. But when he’d announced that he meant to descend the mountain and “serve humanity,” the silence that followed had been so complete that even the candles seemed to burn more carefully.

The Head Abbot had not mocked him. That would have been easier to bear. He had only looked at Astred with the grave pity of a man watching humility take its first step toward pride.

“A kind heart is not the same as a harmless one, Astred.”

Astred had felt every monk in the hall listening.

“Suffering teaches people to answer one another,” the Head Abbot continued. “To resolve their quarrels. To provide for their own hunger. To become, by necessity, more than frightened souls waiting for rescue. Even here, among your brothers, we do not mend every hurt for them. We let them struggle toward wisdom.”

His gaze had settled on Astred.

“Would you go into the world and take that labour from them? Would you teach villages to wait for your hand, your judgment, your strength? Or do you already imagine something grander? Astred the reformer. Astred the righteous. Astred standing against lords and guilds and all the tangled powers of the world, certain that his own virtue will remain clean where theirs has not?

Now, standing halfway down the trail, he felt the weight of that moment settling in. The monastery had been his entire world since he was ten years old. A place of quiet halls, prayerful routines, and stacks of well-thumbed books he could vanish into for days. He didn’t remember his parents’ faces. He didn’t remember his birth village. He remembered monks. Warm hands on his shoulders during meditation. Evenings spent copying manuscripts beside his favorite elder. His real family lived behind those walls.

But none of them believed what he believed.

He tightened his grip on the crude cudgel.

"Meaning comes from service," he murmured—half reciting, half reassuring himself. "Not seclusion."

The wind answered with a soft sigh, as though it had heard this debate before.

Astred forced his feet to move. One careful step. Then another. His shield creaked. His robe caught on another thorn. He tugged it free and attempted to look dignified about it.

The valley village grew closer with each hesitant stride. Smoke rising from chimneys. A few distant figures moving between cottages. Someone’s laundry flapping lazily in the breeze. So normal. So alive.

-------

Crit [1158]: https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1tot7zs/comment/oo57s4x/?context=3