MQ-24 vs MW-59

Hello Casiolian, I’m on the fence between MQ-24 and MW-59. One is iconic classic look. The other one just add up the date which for me it quite useful also with better water resistance.

Does anyone has problem with the water resistance in MQ-24? (Swimming, Shower etc.) The bezel on the back is just the click lock with no screw.

On the other hand MW-59 has the date and screw on the back make it more trustable with the water issue.

But I’ve seen a lot of people use MQ-24 more than MW-59

What your guys think?