Finally landed an offer then got another now it's getting difficult to decide

I have been unemployed for almost a year.then finally I got an offer which was pretty basic 72k + 3k relocation.

As I had no other option I accepted that at that time.

And then an old interview surfaced and they asked me to join a quick call and I told them I have an offer but they eventually made an offer which is significantly higher it stands at 95k + 6.5% annual bonus + 4k sign on bonus

Now me being an honest guy as I had already signed the other offer I informed the recruiter that there is a potential offer even before it came.

He spoke to the hiring manager and the hiring manager also called me to say he will try to match.

But then the offer formally landed in my inbox now I have to accept it today but these guys haven't come back with any counter offer.

But the fact that they invested this much time is making me not give up on them easily.

So I really need advice on what to do ?

I am not trying to flex or anything as I got this offer after a year. So I need some real advice.

They have asked me till tomorrow to inform me but the other HR is asking me to sign it today.