Kathy, PJ, or Kris?

🤔Theories

Even if you’ve only watched a few episodes, you know the island is the big bad. And there’s been multiple implications of sacrifices to try to keep the evil forces at bay.

SO…do you think the writers have been making us dislike a few side characters so much, so we (and the main characters), it makes choosing an “island sacrifice” easy?

Who would you nominate? I think it should be Kathy, but PJ also sucks a lot. Kris is a bit humanized because you can tell she loved her victim friends, and she got some serious payback for the bullying in the Baggage ep, so she’d be a distant third for me.

Posted Jun 5, 2026, 4:47 AM UTC

913
Loading comments…