Jomashop vs r/watchexchange for similar price?

I’m looking into getting a tutor ranger 36 and it’s actually $100 cheaper (3.3k usd vs 3.4k) to get it new on jomashop vs secondhand in good condition from r/watchexchange. I can get it delivered to a no tax state so that is also not a factor.

Originally I was thinking it makes a lot more sense to go new with jomashop but is it worth it to go with watch exchange second hand to get the warranty card from AD? even if it’s same price or slightly more?