Regret..?
Okay I married Elliot for my first ever marriage in the game, I played on a different run through but never got married, and I was so focused on getting perfection this second play through for grandpas evaluation in year three that I kinda rushed it.
I liked Sam a lot at first and intended to marry him but I saw Elliot’s garden and room and liked it so much more for my character. I ended up getting Sam as my secret gift for winter AFTER I married Elliot… and it got me thinking to when I first met all the townies and he was the one I liked first! It took me a whole freaking season to figure out who the hell Elliot was or where he lived!
Then Elliot asked me to have a baby and I just said yes not thinking we would have it and then he told me I was pregnant! I got scared and divorced him cause I didn’t want to have the baby before we were ready! I didn’t have the baby thankfully but I divorced him winter 23 and he was gone the day before the winter festival. He wouldn’t talk to me and I felt horrible! I wasn’t sure if everyone in town knew and worse if they knew I was pregnant! I felt even worse when Gus mentioned he knew about the split at the saloon the next day.. did they all know and just not say anything?!? Robin gave me 99 wood as my gift that year when I already had 999… Elliot would not accept my gifts and said I shattered his hopes and dreams.. maybe cause I KILLED our child!
I married sam and wiped Elliot’s memory clean but now that I’m with Sam I miss Elliot’s sweet little poetic lines and I’m sad he doesn’t remember me. I also loved that he would water our cats bowl and do stuff around the farm.
I kinda wanna marry Elliot again and divorce Sam..
Posted Jun 7, 2026, 4:30 AM UTC