Theory about Roger for S4E7

SpoilerTheory

My theory is that the MIY resurrected Roger. When Rogers wakes up he touches his face. Giving me the thought that he was actually pulled back from the dead and I don’t think that he was actually trying to hurt anyone. He was literally just traumatized and couldn’t see and was trying to figure out what was going on.

Eggs have been used for centuries in different religions for connecting the dead with the living, resurrections and rebirth.

If the MIY just resurrected him, I think he really just wanted to scare the people of Colony house especially after Boyd told everyone about Jade and Tabitha.

I think the MIY relationship with all the monsters is different. I think he has a symbiotic relationship with the town monsters, since they obviously knew about Boyd’s plan because he shared it with Sophia. With how he looked at the ballerina statue I think he feels either horrified/awed by it but most likely because he has no control over it like in town. Maybe he doesn’t even know about all the monsters in the world, like the dolls. Sophia’s face looked surprised when learning about the dolls, but also she is playing the part of naive church girl. So it feels like a wash for me on that part.

Please share your theory or if anything sparked for you with mine, I’d love to theory craft with you guys.

Posted Jun 8, 2026, 4:32 PM UTC

30
Loading comments…