What to do on a Monday night in NYC? Our show will most likely close before we go.

We are going in October and arriving on a Monday. As luck has it, Two Strangers was randomly showing that night so we grabbed tickets. Now, we are afraid it will close. What else should we consider? Any good off-Broadway? We are staying near 8th and 46th and would prefer to be within a 15 minute walk of the theatre.

Our plane lands at 3:15 at JKF so we also have to get to the city. Two Strangers was perfect since it was a 7:30 show and like 5 minutes away.

I was looking at Drunk Shakespeare, but that might be a bit too far from the hotel to make happen for a 7 pm show.