Pirelli P Zero AS Plus 3s vs Pirelli Cinturato WeatherActives

Choosing between these two tires. My G's RWD and I’ve always used all seasons, which are practically bald now. Here, it can get as low as 20f, but it’s usually between 40-50f. We get mild winters, but the roads are plowed really quick. I might still have to drive in 1-2 inches of snow, but it wouldn’t be often.

I don’t think I drive my car enough to get a dedicated winter tire set (around 8000 KM/yr). I’m more worried about the cold weather performance of the P Zeros because I believe they aren’t rated below 40-45f

FWIW I’m running a staggered setup: 275/35 in the back and 245/40 in the front (19 inch wheels).