I'm a 3D character artist by trade and I've always found it kind of hard to get useful feedback on stuff I'm working on. You post a render and it's either "looks sweet" or nothing, and neither really tells you what to fix. I missed having real crits.

I ended up making a small tool around this and I honestly can't tell if it's useful or if I'm overthinking a problem that isn't really a problem.

The main thing it does is let people pin comments directly onto points on your 3D model, so the pins stay on the model as you rotate it instead of someone trying to describe a spot in words. You can also do draw overs for more nuanced feedback. It reads most game formats (GLB/glTF, OBJ, FBX and STL), and there's a halfway decent viewer so you can actually turn the model around on web or mobile without it looking like crap.

That's pretty much it. It's early and it's just me poking at it.

Mostly posting because I'd rather hear from people who actually do critique whether this is worth continuing or whether it already exists / wouldn't fit how you work. Totally fine with "this is pointless," that's useful to know too.

Made a free thing for getting critique on 3D work where you can pin comments onto the actual game model. Not sure if it's useful, curious what you all think