Which paper should I use? Trying to get as close to the sleeved feel of cards as possible.

Currently I am using Koala Double Sided Matte 66lb paper and 3mil laminate. I am also using Bleidruk Holo sticker sheets and putting them on the same Photo paper as a back.

The cards are snappy and feel good enough but are slightly to thick, noticeable of you try to look for them but usable in a casual pod, per my buddy I play with. I was thinking of switching to Koala glossy 48lb but dont want to just buy more and more paper. Would the 48lb feel better in a sleeve? Less noticeable?