1. Hayley Williams - EDAABP (Hayley's Mix): managed to snag it off her webstore, it's one of only 1,500! I was sooo happy :)

2. MCR - I Brought You My Bullets, You Brought Me Your Love: got it from someone on Kijiji for like $25 in 2018, and it has the sampler CD!

3. Frnkiero and the Cellabration - Stomachaches: this one surprised me that it was so valuable, I picked it up for $8 from one of my local record shops on RSD in 2024

4. The Brobecks - Violent Things: this one surprised me too, ordered it new from Dallon's webstore back in 2019 when it was reissued

5. Fall Out Boy - Evening Out With Your Girlfriend: got this one at the same time as the MCR album, also for like $20. It's supposed to have the sampler CD, but it didn't come with it when I got it

6. Tame Impala - Innerspeakers (Limited Edition): picked this one up at the same time as Stomachaches for like $10, was also surprised to see that it's valuable

7. Fall Out Boy - TTTYG: I did not realize this one was so uncommon, I got it brand new from HMV in 2016. Apparently straight from 2003 and the only Canadian pressing!

8. Fall Out Boy - My Heart Will Always Be The B-Side To My Tongue: my first "rare" find in my collection! I found it on Kijiji for $5 in 2016. Still has the DVD too! (side note, my friend got a DVD copy of Release the Bats from the same seller ((iykyk)))

9. Hayley Williams - Flowers for Vases/descansos: I got this one off Discogs a few months ago for $16 and somehow it's up here

10. Silverstein - Discovering the Waterfront: also a Kijiji find in 2017 or so, probably got it for $10 or less. It includes a double sided DVD, one side Silverstein, the other side Bayside. 

Thought it would be fun to share my "most valuable" and how they came to be in my collection! I would love to hear how you all found your most "valuable" CDs (and if you also got them for a good deal lol)

My 10 most valuable! (according to discogs median estimates)