Upcoming trip

My wife and I are in our forties and are heading to Puerto Rico for 6 days. For the second half of the trip we plan on driving to Rincon and staying at an Airbnb, hopefully taking a surfing lesson, doing some snorkeling and just enjoying the area. Trying to decide what to do for the first half of the trip. Should we stay in Isla Verde or go to Luquillo?

​

We want to enjoy the beaches of course, and have a nice night out bar hopping at local spots within walking distance of a hotel or airbnb. Bonus if we stay close enough to visit Old San Juan. We'd also be interested in horseback riding or visiting the rain forest.

​

Appreciate the feedback.