TV Comedies That Don't Tug At The Heartstrings

There's not much that I hate more than being in a bad/upset mood, sitting down to watch a comedy, and ending up in tears because of some touching or heartwarming moment the writers threw in. I'm watching a comedy to laugh and be happy and as soon as that kind of thing starts, I just have to turn it off.

Scrubs is one show that did it all the time. I love the comedy in that show, but I just can't watch it because I get too upset. I stopped watching How I Met Your Mother because that kind of thing also got too overwhelming. Same for The Office.

Most comedies in the past always had a couple of those more serious episodes, which was fine by me. I never liked them, but it was maybe once a season and it was usually focused on some issue (drugs, sexual abuse, etc). Now it seems to be more frequent and more relationship based as opposed to issue based, which would be great... if it wasn't a comedy show.

It seems to me like Friends was a big contributor to this becoming a trend. It was wildly successful and had many touching moments. I also think the change of focus from mostly episodic sitcoms to seasonal story arcs is a factor as well.

Can someone who likes their comedies mixed with touching drama try to explain what's enjoyable about that to you? Also, what shows can I watch that are purely comedy and don't ever try to take themselves too seriously?

I find South Park is usually good for this. Archer as well. Always Sunny has also held up in this department, but some of the Charlie/Waitress stuff has come a little too close for me recently. Arrested Development is also good in this regard. Other examples would be appreciated.

Posted Jan 3, 2014, 3:51 PM UTC

2249
RaplicPriest•

Pure comedy without touchy dramatics, IMO, would be Seinfeld or It's Always Sunny.

56
kimand85•

Also, in that vein, Curb your enthusiasm is a good example.

23
RaplicPriest•

Being a HUGE Seinfeld fan, I surprise a lot of my friends by saying I have never watched Curb.

I want to, I just haven't yet. I think I'll watch it after I'm done binging Seinfeld again.

0
BonquiquiShiquavius•

Just beware - if you can't stand "cringe" comedy, like the UK Office, you won't like Curb. I liked Seinfeld (not a huge fan though), but I couldn't be around when my wife watched Curb. Just too much awkward.

1
madrilenya•

curb your enthusiasm is the most hysterically cringe programme on tv

1
outdabox•

It's much better than Seinfeld. Personally I think Seinfeld was the worst part about Seinfeld. This is Seinfeld given free reign and with out Seinfeld.

0
You_mean_free_rein•

Did you know that the expression 'free rein' originates in relation to horses? Giving a horse free rein means you're allowing it to move around as it pleases - the opposite is to keep it on a tight rein, so you have close control over its movements. Click here for more details.

Now that you know this, please avoid misspelling it as free reign!

1
legogamegirl•

"The Seinfeld motto: no learning, no hugging." - Julia Louis-Dreyfus

13
Ginsoakedboy21•

The "Always Sunny" motto - everyone's an asshole. All the time.

15
Randolpho•

Every once in a while one of them starts sounding like the voice of reason but proves (s)he's an asshole by the third act.

10
vulturetrainer•

I thought it was "the louder you yell, the righter you are"?

3
[deleted]•

The closest I've ever seen Sunny come to a touching moment was the Christmas special I think on season five. The ending where they're all throwing rocks at a train sort of being used as a metaphor for their "delinquent kid" innocence.

1
SpringwoodSlasherOP•

I've never been able to get drawn in by Seinfeld, but from what I've seen you're right. Pretty much pure comedy.

1
Berd89•

Archer is great at this. Even something as cancer is treated with nothing but humor.

Also, Brooklyn Ninte-Nine has yet to do anything of this sort, and by the wibe of the show, I don't expect something like that anytime soon.

25
RaplicPriest•

Archer is weird with it, because they bait you with a [heartbreaking scene](#s "Katya dying and Archer screaming "KATYA, NOOO!"") then Adam Reed tears the rug from under you and puts in the [comedy](#s "Krieger screams "MY VAN!"")

Spoiler tags, just in case.

9
JHW12•

"Why are you crying?"

"sniff My van..."

2
SpringwoodSlasherOP•

I've heard good things about Brooklyn Nine-Nine. Not usually into cop shows, but if it's funny I could end up liking it. Someone else mentioned Reno 911 as another one and I do love that show as well.

3
mrfujidoesacid•

I've been trying to get as many people to watch Brooklyn Nine-Nine as possible. It's been amazingly solid and fully realized since the first episode, and I'm amazed that it's been able to keep up with the pace it set for itself. It's very much like Parks & Rec in a police department (it's even created by Parks & Rec alum).

2
squidactually•

There has been some mildly heartwarming stuff in B99, but nothing sad.

1
humanehawk•

Have you watched 30 rock. It never gets very heavy, at least as much as I remember.

12
SpringwoodSlasherOP•

On season 5 of it now actually and it's pretty consistently funny.

2
travio•

Charley really is the only person on Always Sunny that I find myself caring at all about. But outside those few sad moments it fits your bill. The League is pretty similar in that regard. There are very few tugs at the heart in that show. Give it a try even if you are not a football fan, the fantasy football angle is usually pretty minimum. You will miss a few references but not enough to make the show hard to understand.

10
Keldon888•

Charlie goes like 9 yards of sympathy, then is a complete monster for that last step.

4
BonquiquiShiquavius•

Definitely try The League. I'm not a football fan at all, which is why I avoided the series in the first place. But man is it funny (if you don't mind crude humour). And the fantasy football parts of it are short and spaced enough that they don't take away from the show.

The NFL guest star episodes are generally much less enjoyable to me though.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
RobotBuddha•

I only gave in and tried The League pretty recently. The idea of a show centered around fantasy football fans just seemed to be the most boring premise I could imagine. But I was pleasantly surprised by how much I ended up liking it. I feel like the writing can get a little lazy at times, but for the most part it's a pretty solid sitcom.

1
fatblank•

Workaholics.

Always sunny in Philadelphia

Family Guy, for the most part

9
reboundmc•

Corner Gas, always just lighthearted, clean, tongue in cheek, gentle comedy. Also, it goes way, way back before Friends. Ever see MASH or All in the Family, or heck, even the Brady Bunch got serious from time to time.

8
strengthofstrings•

I don't really mind shows that mix comedy and drama to a certain point. Real life is not non-stop laughs nor is it all "srs bsns" all the time. I think it works best in shows that have a realistic feel, like Roseanne, as opposed to a standard sitcom with "very special episodes" or a show like Modern Family that tacks on a schmaltzy ending all the time...then it feels hokey and artificial.

For shows that stick to pure comedy, try Reno 911 or Married With Children.

6
carydog•

Seinfeld and Curb Your Enthusiasm have both never had one single serious moment. God love 'em.

6
ConradBHart42•

If you don't mind "off the wall" stuff or a total lack of continuity or maybe some juvenile humor, stuff from [adult swim] tends to be really funny. Aqua Teen Hunger Force is probably the best known. Sealab 2021 is my favorite, and it's made by the same guy as Archer. He has another show called Frisky Dingo that I didn't watch, but I doubt it has any emotional content. The early stuff from [as] tends to be less random and weird and generally less aimed-at-stoners.

Ugly Americans is a good outing from CC. There's some romance and stuff peppered in, but it's never really heavy or particularly touching because it's all so absurd. Drawn Together is DEFINITELY never touching, but uses a lot of juvenile/grossout humor.

4
LaunchpadMacQ•

Unfortunately, many comedies have tried to dabble in the drama category and ultimately come up short. I know that's not really your point, but it's actually why I stopped watching HIMYM. lol

It's unfortunate, but you've named every single comedy that I would recommend for someone looking for one-off comedy, no strings attached. The better comedies I can think of (Parks and Rec, Modern Family, Louie) even rely on drama at times, even though they do so successfully. What I enjoy about them is that they flesh out the characters in such a way that feels natural. I'm not really huge on the "comedy" genre, either, because I find that I get the best comedic value from dramas, ironically enough. However, obviously, that comes with the caveat that these shows are the same ones that end up getting me all emotional or making me think.

Oh, but there is Seinfeld. Best comedy of all time, imo, and not heartwarming in the slightest. lol

2
DoubleLeg71•

Parks and Rec really doesn't have much downside plus Ron Swanson alone is enough of a reason to watch

2
mrfujidoesacid•

Trailer Park Boys. There are some emotional scenes mainly involving Bubbles, but they are few and far between (and in most cases, I think, relegated to the specials and movies primarily). Otherwise it's just an amazing farce that gets better and better the more you binge.

IT Crowd is another one that never goes for the heartstrings. Very similar to Seinfeld after the rocky first season. Hilarious, absurd fun. Never heavy.

I'm tempted to include Raising Hope in this discussion if only because their take on the "tug at your heartstrings" stuff is so blissfully slathered in ridiculousness that it never gets too mopey.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
chezo•

I think how I met doesn't really get too touchy and its still hilarious. Same with big bang

1
TeddyWestchester•

Really? How much of HIMYM have you watched? It is WAY touchy.

1