2016 countryman or 2012/2010 hatchback?

Are any of these good cars?

2016 - 85,000 miles / 4.5k (£)

2012 - 89,000 miles / 2.6k

2010 - 67,000 miles / 3k

All the MOT histories are fine. I’m waiting to hear back about service reports. I had an accident that wasn’t my fault but now really need a car. All the cars I see driving on the road that people seem to enjoy (such as Minis) have god awful ratings/ reviews here on Reddit and I’m just getting so confused by what I should do!