Don't Get a Radical Nephrectomy Without a Second Opinion
I am 38 years old. Around 2 months ago I had an MRI due to unexplained issues with my heart racing, facial flushing, and waking up feeling like I was suffocating if I slept on my left side. That MRI was the last test in a series of tests trying to identify some problem with my heart. It did not see a problem with my heart, but the edge of the MRI did catch a mass on my kidney. This led to an abdominal CT scan that confirmed a ~5.7 cm tumor that was likely renal cell carcinoma.
I was referred to a very experienced surgeon at Vanderbilt, which has a Urology department that is in the top 25 in the country. He told me that based on my scans, he recommended a radical nephrectomy and that a partial was not likely possible. I was shocked, but figured that was the best option. I have an extra kidney anyway, right? But then I started reading studies from the past couple of decades and they were all pointing to one thing: A partial nephrectomy is far superior to a radical if it removes the entire tumor. And the difference isn't small.
Outcomes from partial nephrectomies are at least equal to, and often many times better, than radical nephrectomies across every category that I have seen. Lower rates of dialysis, lower rates of heart disease, lower rates of all cause mortality, and even lower rates of death from kidney cancer itself! If you remove one kidney and the other kidney develops cancer, you are screwed. You need a transplant at that point, and the anti rejection drugs needed with a transplant will greatly increase the odds of the cancer growing elsewhere. But if you have 75% of one kidney and the other kidney develops cancer, you probably will just end up with 75% of each kidney, which still outperforms a single kidney at 100%. And the lifestyle changes needed to live successfully with a single kidney are significant. People act like it isn't a big deal, but it means a low sodium, low potassium, and low protein diet. And you must avoid many medications. It also becomes incredibly important to avoid high blood pressure, but only having a single kidney increases blood pressure itself, which can be really rough for someone like me who already had hypertension beforehand.
Anyway, knowing all of this, I started looking at my options. I quickly decided that I was going to go to one of the leading cancer centers to get a second opinion. Memorial Sloan Kettering is ranked #1 in the country for urological cancer and Dr. Paul Russo has been a leader in the field of kidney cancer surgery for decades, so I made an appointment with him. And Mount Sinai is ranked #6 for urological cancer, and it is right down the street from MSK, so I asked around and got referred to Dr. Reza Mehrazin. I was able to get both appointments scheduled within a week of each other and the first of these was only 2 weeks out from when I called. These surgeons are at the top of their field, but they have openings. You CAN see the best.
Anyway, I went to both of these appointments and both surgeons agreed on one thing: I should not get a radical nephrectomy. They could not promise that they could successfully do a partial, and both noted that my tumor was fairly complex, but both also said that it did not look like anything out of the ordinary for them and expected that there was a high chance of a successful PN. Dr. Russo did not give me any odds, but Dr. Mehrazin said 90%+. It was primarily contingent on whether the cancer had invaded my sinus fat or not, as that was not completely clear from the scans. The two doctors did disagree on the method of my surgery, as it seems there is an ongoing debate in the field between whether open surgery or laproscopic robotic surgery is the better option. The research I have found did not show any significant difference between the two in terms of cancer removal, but open does have a higher rate of complications. Dr. Russo has some ongoing research suggesting there could be some other issues with robotic, but the picture isn't clear and it may be more related to the expertise of the surgeon than the method. Robotic is a newer technology, so a surgeon who specializes in open is going to have more years of experience on average. But I digress. In the end, I chose robotic with Dr. Mehrazin. He was able to do my surgery sooner, and I wanted this thing out of me, and through family friends I had found people who had worked with him in the past and they all suggested that he was an exceptional surgeon.
Anyway, my surgery was around a week ago. The tumor was completely removed with negative margins. That means in the couple of millimeters of healthy kidney that they removed with the tumor, there was no cancer detected. Also samples were taken from the sinus fat within the kidney as well as the fat sheath that surrounds the kidney and both also were negative for cancer. I retained 75% of my kidney and I am not expected to lose any significant function, as the 2 mm of healthy tissue that was removed was the only functional portion of the kidney that was removed. The tumor was already non-functional. And my eGFR was very good before surgery. So I will likely have kidney function that is at least as good as the average person. Beyond the scars and ongoing MRIs, it will be like it didn't happen.
So please, don't get a radical nephrectomy just because the first surgeon you talk to recommends it. If you have the option, go to a cancer center that is ranked in the top 10 for Urology and get a second opinion. Maybe a third too. And if you can't make it to one of those, try to find the surgeon or surgeons who specialize in kidney cancer at the best cancer center you can get to. And if you are being told that it needs to be radical, ask why. There are reasons that it is recommended in some cases. For example if it is invading the sinus fat then the cancer is automatically stage 3 and it becomes urgent to get the kidney out right away. There may be situations where it can still be saved, but my understanding is that is usually going to be radical. Similarly if the cancer is invading the primary vein that leaves the kidney. But the vast majority of kidney cancers can at least have a partial nephrectomy attempted. And during that attempt, if the surgeon determines that they are not going to be able to completely remove the cancer and still be able to stitch the kidney back together in a functional way, they can shift to a radical mid surgery. They are already 95% of the way to doing it, so it doesn't even add much time.
Posted Jun 24, 2026, 5:40 PM UTC