Help me fill the void left by Voicemails for Isabelle (and erase the memory of Every Year After)

I’ve officially hit the post-binge void.

I’m looking for something to match the high of my permanent obsession, The Summer I Turned Pretty, and my newest hyper-fixation, Voicemails for Isabelle (literally watched it twice in two days, it's great). Off Campus was a good ride, too. But I need something to completely wash out the taste of Every Year After, which was a total waste of my life.

Give me your best, most addictive romance/drama recommendations!