My two surgeons disagreed and now I'm not sure what to think

I'm looking to do an abdominoplasty because I was 230-235 lbs ten years ago, but now I'm 165 (6'1, male, 34yo).

The first surgeon started talking about a mini-TT, but then changed his mind and decided I'm a better candidate for a full TT. So I was like okay that sounds good.

Then I met with the second surgeon, and he decided I'm not a good candidate for a TT at all, and refunded me and referred me to this other surgeon in town who does abdominal etching (hi-def lipo).

Not sure what to think. For what it's worth, not sure if you think it makes a difference, but the first surgeon said he does 150 (!) abdominoplasties a year, while the second one said he does 25.