MG S5 vs ID4 pro

Looking for some advice, maybe somebody on here was in a similar situation.

Buying a brand new EV next month. I’m torn between the MG S5 (top spec) and the ID4 pro. The MG was lovely and really liked it, getting roughly €400 a month finance over 5 years with the deposit im willing to put down.

The ID4 on the other hand finance is too expensive but PCP is working out nicely around €340 a month over 3 years and obviously final payment and all that goes with that then where as at least the MG is mine at the end.

Money side of things aside though they felt very similar, have almost identical specs and real world range from what I can tell. I don’t do huge milage probably 15-20km a year.

Anyone any experience with either that might sway me? Am I better off going with the tried and tested VW that should in theory hold its value better??

Thanks in advance