Melanie bby…
I have actually grown to LOVE Melanie especially after the last episode where you could genuinely feel the sisterhood through the screen the way she was comforting Aniya.
Which brings me to my point. During that moment, Melanie got emotional because she was feeling empathy for Aniya, however, I think she also got emotional because she is feeling the same way to a certain degree (which we all know) but that’s why it breaks my heart.
Melanie STILL FKN chose Sincere and it’s almost like she did that to prove a point to him like “look babe I keep choosing you”, instead of going where the reciprocity really was i.e. Corey. Now, we only got a few episodes with Corey but never once did he move slimy off rip. Trinity was honest with him, he took it on the chin and focused all of his energy on someone else.
Sincere deserved every word Melanie said up there when he came back from casa, and like the fact that she stood there and she said that she felt embarrassed that all the casa boys were telling her he’s not good news that’s should have been enough. And I get it, sometimes we just want someone to act right and be who you want them to be but I really hope Melanie realizes that he is not going to change unless he wants to. And tbh why would he if you reward his poor behaviour with another chance? That’s just him pushing the boundary every time.
And what pisses me off the most is the fact that he thinks he’s a good guy because he went to Casa and did not come back with a girl, but that is simply because he genuinely got to have his cake and eat it too. He got to go to Casa and do whatever he wanted to because Melanie wasn’t around and then have the audacity to say I still chose you and it’s like sincere you chose her because you knew at the end of the day she was probably gonna choose you to.
That’s the problem like these men do what they want because they know if the girl loves them enough and knows how to push the boundary they can get away with anything and that’s literally what he’s doing.
And Melanie literally made a point in the last episode about how dumb it sounds to say like “oh yeah, but he’s coming home to me though” and that’s exactly what she’s doing :(
And one last thing, if she felt all those negative emotions with Sincere, I don’t understand the thought process behind choosing him again only because it’s not like Corey is just gonna chill on the island. Like after not choosing him like that story between them is now dead until the show is over. She honestly did herself a disservice, and my heart breaks for her.
Posted Jun 29, 2026, 11:38 PM UTC