Complete breakdown 48 hours after tuneup.
Hello Experts - Have a question regarding a significant failure following a furnace (and AC) tune-up by a reputable local company and I'm wondering how hard to pursue this.
Equipment: Aire-Flo gas furnace (15yrs)
Last Wednesday I completed a furnace tune-up. Following the appointment, the tech documented that unit was in proper working order, but observed a clicking noise coming from the blower after servicing the unit. He believes that the clicking is likely from the screw holes expanding overtime from the blower vibrations and he was unable to do anything to stop the noise.
He advised that the clicking noise may *eventually* require a new blower, but the only recommended was to replace 2 capacitors ($650) which i did.
* By Friday (T+2 days) the clicking noise was loud enough to be audible upstairs through the vents.
* By Saturday (T+3 days) the blower motor was **very** loud when operating which I immediately cut power to the unit as soon as I noticed.
I had the company back out today (same tech) and his diagnosis is that the blower bearing has failed and needs to be immediately replaced along with the control board which is now showing obvious signs of burnt out resistors. - He believes the blower 'ran too hard and burnt out the control board' in the few days following the initial service call. - Total quote is $3500~to replace those two parts and he's leaning hard into the "it's just a coincidence" angle.
Obviously timing is suspect, but the tech also lost some credibility with me. - Immediately following the initial appointment we noticed that our AC was not working and a second call-out was needed to identify that the AC Compressor cable had not been plugged back into the control board. Mistakes happen, but it's enough to make me skeptical of the techs abilities.
What do we think? - Incorrect re-installation of the blower leading to the the premature failure? Or just unlucky timing?
Posted Jul 3, 2026, 6:01 PM UTC