This is a theory i’ve seen throughout multiple scources and my own binge through the show after s4 im gonna break it down in sections but first ill start with the main logic behind the theory       
 \\\*\\\*At the end of S2 and the beginning of S3 we see the photos in Henry’s basement that Miranda drew before she discovered the town that itself is a great representation that pictures are for shadows of the full on story throughout the show we see victors drawings from the past present and future and i don’t think it just stops there\\\*\\\* 

**Photo 1:** in season 1 Episode 7 on the backwall of Fatima’s room you see a picture of a woman who resembles her turning into one of the monsters that’s pure foreshadow of what is to come in season 4 and we looked right over it. this isn’t nothing crazy but just further evidence to back up my theory.

**Photo 2:** I don’t exactly remember the episode but in the beginning of the episode Ethan is looking at pictures that Victor has drawn overtime and one of them is a picture of Boyd with a goat coming out the woods like 15-20 minutes later Boyd then walks right out the woods with a goat next to him NOT A COINCIDENCE. 

**Photo 3:** This is where I believe the photos become the most interesting because this one is in our face from the beginning, We have all 3 forms of the MIY. The true form,       
Sophia and best of all the DOG, in season 1 when they are explaining how Boyd found the talismans he gets lured in the woods by a dog with that happening is all a ripple effect of the MIY work. He sent Boyd out which finished the work on Abby that he was doing since she thought Boyd died she lost control of her mental state and went on a murder spree that then created a gap in Boyd’s relationship with Ellis due to the fact that Ellis watched Boyd murder his mother right infront of him. This was all Carefully arranged by the MIY to start the games with Boyd that have now carried on all the way to S4 Boyd is this towns favorite toy to play with and it was shown since the start. Another time when the dog arrives is after Boyd gets out the well and the dungeon with Martin. We all believe Martin was a form of the MIY pushing the story further along with the games with Boyd and the moment Martin transfers the blood and Boyd is able to leave the dog appears right outside waiting for him again THIS SHOW DOES NOT HAVE COINCIDENCES. 

**Photo 4:** This is a separate theory but it is also backed by this theory so i thought why not add it. Since Randall arrived in the beginning of S2 he’s never really had an important role yet in the beginning of S3 when the ambulance arrives Boyd has to trade Randall for the keys and the monsters spared randall. They do not do that they kill throughout 4 seasons we never seen that happen so what i am thinking is randall had some type of deal done with the monsters or maybe they already knew he was apart of their side but they couldn’t let it be obvious so they had to leave some time of attack on him just not one that would kill him. On top of that we know that people come here to play roles for the most part and that 2 people can be the same role at once for example Victor and Ethan. The photo above shows all the resemblances which obviously help the case and again THIS SHOW DOES NOT HAVE COINCIDENCES. i think the shirt and picture of the MIY with a scar that resembles Randall’s are the strongest points to back this theory up but also the fact that he is so hesitant to stop Julie from Story walking right after she discovered the man in yellow why not any time before hand why wait till that exact story where she is getting close to the truth? 

**Photo 5&6:** these 2 are different I believe these both will tell us the events of S5. In s4 the MIY is holding a fireman’s hat i don’t think that was just a random coincidence again I think a fire will happen at the colony house after Sophia discovers that there is still a talisman left in the basement to try and get them out the house to take it. The flood I believe will be the end of our story, When we seen the flashback of Abby Boyd and Ellis when they traveled into the town and Boyd was talking about his dream boat I think that was ultimate foreshadowing of what’s to come. Just as the town runs on Nightmares and fear It also feeds off of hope so what if it maybe could create dreams.. Then when Boyd is trapped in the well he has a vision of Ellis handing him the boat keys again COINCIDENCES ARE NOT A THING IN THIS SHOW!!! I believe the boat will have a big impact or role in S5 and the flood that we will be experiencing. 

\\\*\\\*That is my full theory on this show please feel free to leave your opinions or Theories i’m sorry for the blabber none of my family watches this show and i love it and have been watching for a while now\\\*\\\*

My Picture Theory: Am i going crazy or am i putting the pieces together ?