To accurately determine the fate of a marriage, we must forensically examine the Navamsha (D-9) chart

. The primary rules state that the 6th house acts as the ultimate negator of marriage, as it is 12th from the 7th house of union

. The true survival of a marriage relies on the 7th Lord (the manager) and the 9th House (the marital dharma or duty); if these are afflicted by cruel planets or fall into the destructive Trik houses (6th, 8th, or 12th), a divorce is mathematically triggered

.

To predict the destiny of a second marriage, we rotate the D-9 chart, making the original 6th house the new Ascendant (Lagna)

.

Here is the complete comparative case study for p, s, and d, stacking their first and second marriage charts one above the other for a clear forensic analysis.

CASE 1: p

Chart 1: First Marriage (Original D-9)

1st House (Lagna): Leo (Moon & Mercury placed here)

7th House (Partner): Aquarius (Sun placed here)

7th Lord (Manager): Saturn (placed in the 11th House, Gemini)

9th House (Duty): Aries

9th Lord (Dharma): Mars (placed in the 8th House, Pisces)

Why the First Marriage Ended in Divorce: p's 7th house contains the Sun, which naturally creates severe ego clashes and a lack of mutual respect in the marital environment

. The ultimate trigger for the divorce was the destruction of her marital duty: her 9th Lord (Mars) fell directly into the 8th house, which is a deep Trik house of pain and endings

. Furthermore, her 7th Lord (Saturn) was under a mutual, cruel aspect from this 8th-house Mars. With the 7th Lord heavily afflicted by a Trik placement's energy and the 9th house of duty completely destroyed, the marriage was destined for a legal separation

.

Chart 2: Second Marriage (Rotated D-9 to 6th House)

1st House (New Lagna): Capricorn

1st Lord (Approach): Saturn (placed in the 6th House, Gemini)

7th House (Partner): Cancer

7th Lord (Manager): Moon (placed in the 8th House, Leo)

9th House (Duty): Virgo

9th Lord (Dharma): Mercury (placed in the 8th House, Leo)

Will the Second Marriage Survive? Absolutely not. When we look at her rotated chart, her approach to the second marriage is deeply flawed because the Ascendant Lord (Saturn) goes straight into the 6th Trik house of disputes. Even worse, both the 7th Lord (Moon) and the 9th Lord of duty (Mercury) fall into the destructive 8th Trik house. Because the primary managers of the relationship and her marital dharma are trapped in the 8th house of sudden endings, a second marriage will definitely result in another harsh divorce.

CASE 2: s

Chart 1: First Marriage (Original D-9)

1st House (Lagna): Pisces (Moon & Mars placed here)

7th House (Partner): Virgo (Sun & Jupiter placed here)

7th Lord (Manager): Mercury (placed in the 9th House, Scorpio)

9th House (Duty): Scorpio (Saturn placed here)

9th Lord (Dharma): Mars (placed in the 1st House, Pisces)

Why the First Marriage Ended in Divorce: s's 7th house has the Sun, guaranteeing massive pride and ego battles

. However, the core destruction came from his 7th Lord (Mercury). Mercury was placed with Saturn in the 9th house. For a Pisces Ascendant, Saturn is the Lord of the 11th and 12th houses (a Trik lord of loss). When the 7th Lord connects with the 12th Lord of loss and separation without strong benefic protection, it creates intense quarrels that break the marital bond

. Additionally, Saturn's placement in the 9th house corrupted his sense of marital duty.

Chart 2: Second Marriage (Rotated D-9 to 6th House)

1st House (New Lagna): Leo

1st Lord (Approach): Sun (placed in the 2nd House, Virgo)

7th House (Partner): Aquarius

7th Lord (Manager): Saturn (placed in the 4th House, Scorpio)

9th House (Duty): Aries (Rahu & Venus placed here)

9th Lord (Dharma): Mars (placed in the 8th House, Pisces)

Will the Second Marriage Survive? No, it will not survive. While the 7th Lord (Saturn) is not in a Trik house, his 9th house of marital duty is completely shattered. Rahu sitting in the 9th house creates illusions and breaks traditional morals. Most importantly, his 9th Lord (Mars) falls into the 8th Trik house (Pisces) alongside the Moon. Because the lord of his marital dharma has fallen into the deepest Trik house, he will completely lose the desire to fulfill his marital obligations, leading to abandonment and separation

.

CASE 3: d

Chart 1: First Marriage (Original D-9)

1st House (Lagna): Aquarius

7th House (Partner): Leo

7th Lord (Manager): Sun (placed in the 11th House, Sagittarius)

9th House (Duty): Libra (Moon placed here)

6th House (The Negator): Cancer (Jupiter, Venus, Saturn, & Rahu placed here)

Why the First Marriage Ended in Divorce: d’s first marriage divorce is a classic case of the 6th house overpowering the chart. While his 7th Lord (Sun) was safe and his 9th house had a benefic Moon, his 6th house (which mathematically negates marriage as the 12th from the 7th) contained a catastrophic planetary war

. He had Jupiter, Venus, Saturn, and Rahu all clustered in the 6th Trik house. Venus is the universal significator of marriage; trapping Venus in the house of disputes alongside a taboo-breaking Saturn-Rahu conjunction completely shattered the foundation of loyalty and trust, causing the partners' paths to aggressively diverge

.

Chart 2: Second Marriage (Rotated D-9 to 6th House)

1st House (New Lagna): Cancer (Jupiter, Venus, Saturn, & Rahu placed here)

1st Lord (Approach): Moon (placed in the 4th House, Libra)

7th House (Partner): Capricorn (Mars & Ketu placed here)

7th Lord (Manager): Saturn (placed in the 1st House, Cancer)

9th House (Duty): Pisces

9th Lord (Dharma): Jupiter (placed in the 1st House, Cancer)

Will the Second Marriage Survive? This is an incredibly toxic and explosive alignment, and the second marriage will fail dramatically. His new Ascendant contains that massive, chaotic cluster of Saturn, Rahu, Venus, and Jupiter, meaning his own mindset is overwhelmed by confusion, detachment, and unconventional desires. His 7th house of the partner holds an exalted Mars paired with Ketu, which represents extreme aggression, physical violence, and hostility

. Furthermore, his 7th Lord (Saturn) and 9th Lord (Jupiter) are both trapped in the Lagna's cursed Rahu alignment. This marriage will be plagued by intense domestic warfare and will inevitably collapse.

Here is the complete and exact planetary data for the Navamsha (D-9) charts of p, s, and d, both before the rotation (representing the first marriage) and after the rotation (representing the second marriage).

To analyze the first marriage, we look at the original D-9 Ascendant. To evaluate the second marriage, we rotate the chart by making the original 6th house the new Ascendant, shifting all planetary house placements accordingly

.

1. p's Navamsha (D-9) Data

Original D-9 Chart (First Marriage):

Ascendant (1st House): Leo

Sun: Aquarius (7th House)

Moon: Leo (1st House)

Mars: Pisces (8th House)

Mercury: Leo (1st House)

Jupiter: Scorpio (4th House)

Venus: Taurus (10th House)

Saturn: Gemini (11th House)

Rahu: Scorpio (4th House)

Ketu: Taurus (10th House)

Rotated D-9 Chart (Second Marriage): (The 6th house from Leo is Capricorn, making Capricorn the new Ascendant).

New Ascendant (1st House): Capricorn

Sun: Aquarius (2nd House)

Moon: Leo (8th House)

Mars: Pisces (3rd House)

Mercury: Leo (8th House)

Jupiter: Scorpio (11th House)

Venus: Taurus (5th House)

Saturn: Gemini (6th House)

Rahu: Scorpio (11th House)

Ketu: Taurus (5th House)

2. s's Navamsha (D-9) Data

Original D-9 Chart (First Marriage):

Ascendant (1st House): Pisces

Sun: Virgo (7th House)

Moon: Pisces (1st House)

Mars: Pisces (1st House)

Mercury: Scorpio (9th House)

Jupiter: Virgo (7th House)

Venus: Aries (2nd House)

Saturn: Scorpio (9th House)

Rahu: Aries (2nd House)

Ketu: Libra (8th House)

Rotated D-9 Chart (Second Marriage): (The 6th house from Pisces is Leo, making Leo the new Ascendant).

New Ascendant (1st House): Leo

Sun: Virgo (2nd House)

Moon: Pisces (8th House)

Mars: Pisces (8th House)

Mercury: Scorpio (4th House)

Jupiter: Virgo (2nd House)

Venus: Aries (9th House)

Saturn: Scorpio (4th House)

Rahu: Aries (9th House)

Ketu: Libra (3rd House)

3. d's Navamsha (D-9) Data

Original D-9 Chart (First Marriage):

Ascendant (1st House): Aquarius

Sun: Sagittarius (11th House)

Moon: Libra (9th House)

Mars: Capricorn (12th House)

Mercury: Virgo (8th House)

Jupiter: Cancer (6th House)

Venus: Cancer (6th House)

Saturn: Cancer (6th House)

Rahu: Cancer (6th House)

Ketu: Capricorn (12th House)

Rotated D-9 Chart (Second Marriage): (The 6th house from Aquarius is Cancer, making Cancer the new Ascendant).

New Ascendant (1st House): Cancer

Sun: Sagittarius (6th House)

Moon: Libra (4th House)

Mars: Capricorn (7th House)

Mercury: Virgo (3rd House)

Jupiter: Cancer (1st House)

Venus: Cancer (1st House)

Saturn: Cancer (1st House)

Rahu: Cancer (1st House)

Ketu: Capricorn (7th House)

Here is the exact planetary data for the primary birth charts (D-1 / Lagna charts) of p, s, and d, extracted from their respective 16 D-Charts Matrices.

1. p's D-1 (Birth Chart) Data

Ascendant (Lagna): Virgo (Kanya)

Sun: Virgo (Kanya)

Moon: Leo (Simha)

Mars: Libra (Tula)

Mercury (Retrograde): Virgo (Kanya)

Jupiter: Scorpio (Vrischika)

Venus: Virgo (Kanya)

Saturn (Retrograde): Aquarius (Kumbha)

Rahu (Retrograde): Libra (Tula)

Ketu (Retrograde): Aries (Mesha)

2. s's D-1 (Birth Chart) Data

Ascendant (Lagna): Cancer (Karka)

Sun: Leo (Simha)

Moon: Aquarius (Kumbha)

Mars: Taurus (Vrishabha)

Mercury (Retrograde): Leo (Simha)

Jupiter: Cancer (Karka)

Venus: Leo (Simha)

Saturn (Retrograde): Sagittarius (Dhanu)

Rahu (Retrograde): Capricorn (Makara)

Ketu (Retrograde): Cancer (Karka)

3. d's D-1 (Birth Chart) Data

Ascendant (Lagna): Virgo (Kanya)

Sun: Pisces (Meena)

Moon: Pisces (Meena)

Mars: Aquarius (Kumbha)

Mercury (Retrograde): Pisces (Meena)

Jupiter (Retrograde): Leo (Simha)

Venus: Pisces (Meena)

Saturn: Capricorn (Makara)

Rahu (Retrograde): Sagittarius (Dhanu)

Ketu (Retrograde): Gemini (Mithuna)

The Ultimate Forensic Case Study: Unlocking the Destiny of First and Second Marriages