r/fatlogic•
edrec

Fatlogic at TED: "Why dieting doesn't usually work"

Posted Jan 9, 2014, 8:47 AM UTC

87
Jonas_soe•

What do people think dieting is? Eating 1000 kcal of salad and chocolate flavoured protein powder every day until you're thin and then start eating like a hambeast again, because it's "ok now that you're thin"? Of course diets don't work for you if you think you can just go back to your old eating habits afterwards.

6
A_macaroni_pro•

Exactly. It's like saying, "Diabetics who stop taking their insulin will see their symptoms worsen, therefore insulin doesn't work."

2
nellybellissima•

Erm, I actually agree with the majority of the things she said.

I do think that ACTUAL intuitive eating is a better alternative to spending your whole life counting calories. I do think that counting calories for at least a while is important to give you a proper idea of how much you should be eating and to shrink your stomach to a reasonable size, after that though only eating when you're actually hungry is a good way to go in my opinion.

From what I've heard of set points, not what people use as an excuse, it genuinely makes a lot of sense. The idea that your brain knows how big your body should be and tries to preserve that makes sense. It also makes sense that over time that could get distorted and break a wonderful function. Our bodies evolved to survive periods of not having food, it was very good at it, but we are in a different environment.

I do, however, hate the statistic that young girls who diet, no matter their starting weight, are five times more likely to be overweight. At this point, the U.S. has nearly a 70% overweight or obese population, how can you possibly account for that fact that 2 out of every 3 people have a weight problem anyway. (If that doesn't make a lot of sense I apologize I can't think of a better way to word it) Similar thing goes for the bit about dieting not working. If some people gain even more weight after having dieted isn't it entirely possible that they would have gained the exact same weight if they had never dieted at all? Even more possibly?

3
JagerJack•

She contradicts herself multiple times on set points alone.

First she says that a person's metabolism can never be made normal. Then she says that it takes "as long as" (In reality it's closer to several years) seven years to fix a set point. Then she says set points don't change?!?! Which is it?

Also, while there are multiple reasons why the study she used to "prove" obese people can be healthy is bullshit, I'll just point out that the study relied on the self-reporting of healthy habits. The subjects weren't monitored. Do I even need to say more than that?

Like TiTP, she uses the fact that the way our body works makes dieting difficult, and then extrapolates that to the conclusion that dieting "doesn't work". In reality, diets don't work because people are lazy. People are just to fucking blinded by "teh feels" to blame the users.

4
itoucheditforacookie/r/fitness cuz I hate cankles•

I loved the "Your body naturally knows when to eat and will want to stay within 10-15 lbs of your natural weight." Really? Why the hell are there 700-900 lb people? Their bodies naturally want to be moved around by a bulldozer?

3
heidurzo•

In reality, diets don't work because people are lazy.

Exactly. Going on a diet is simply a change in eating habits in order to lose weight. It can't succeed or fail, it's the person going on the diet who fails or succeeds.

2
Icebein•

At the beginning of her speech she says she lost 10 pounds and by her bodylanguage she is proud of that. But according to her theory, she should gain it all back because of her set point. A little puzzling.

1