ST broke the rules by kicking me without adding Hell’s Librarian first. AITA for demanding a Hell’s Librarian token before being removed?
So apparently my Storyteller kicked me from an online game just because I was being “loud,” “disruptive,” "homophobic" and “awful to everyone."
Except Hell’s Librarian wasn’t even in play.
As everyone knows, the ST isn't allowed to give a bad consquence for talking over them without a Hells Libarian in play. Otherwise, kicking someone is mechanically illegal and the entire game should be discounted.
I repeatedly explained this at maximum volume. The ST refused to acknowledge that the rulebook clearly says consequences only exist when represented by a character token.
Honestly, this is why Clocktower is dying. Storytellers just invent arbitrary house rules like “you cannot scream over everyone” and “stop insulting the other players” and "don't be homophobic" instead of respecting the game mechanics.
AITA for demanding a Hell’s Librarian token before being removed?
Posted Jul 11, 2026, 1:15 PM UTC