Used 2019 Raven Model X (5-seat, HW3) vs. brand new Model Y (HW4) — similar price where I live. Which would you pick?
Hey everyone, looking for some input from X owners here.
I'm trying to decide between a used 2019 Raven Model X (5-seat config, HW3) and a brand new Model Y with HW4. Where I live, they're priced about the same, which makes this a tougher call than I expected.
A bit of context: I currently drive a 2019 Model 3 Long Range RWD, so I'm already familiar with the Tesla ecosystem. This would be an upgrade for more space.
What's drawing me to the X: the Raven refresh (adaptive air suspension, better efficiency), falcon wing doors, and honestly it just feels like a lot more car for the money. But I'm also aware it's a 6-7 year old vehicle at this point — out of warranty, and I've read mixed things about falcon wing door reliability and repair costs.
The Model Y would be new, under full warranty, with HW4 and newer cameras — which matters to me for the long run, since it's unclear how well HW3 cars will be supported for future FSD updates. But it's a smaller car and feels less special.
For those of you who've owned a Raven X (especially higher-mileage ones): how has reliability been? Any major repairs I should budget for? And does the HW3 vs HW4 gap factor into your thinking? Would you buy a Raven X again today over a new Y at the same price?
Appreciate any advice, thanks!
Posted Jul 23, 2026, 5:13 AM UTC