Alternatives for EltaMD Skin Recovery Light Moisturizer? [Product Request]

I’ve been using this moisturizer for at least 4-5 years after being recommended by my derm. However, the most recent purchase from a few months ago caused stinging and turning my cheeks red (but only there - no reactions anywhere else on my face).

I’ve seen some posts across Reddit where people are claiming it was reformulated but unfortunately, I don’t have any of my old bottles to prove this. Plus, the price has jumped dramatically over the last year.

Does anyone have any substitutes? For reference, my skin is acne prone and sensitive. I live in a year-round humid climate so I liked that EltaMD’s was very light and played well with my other skincare products and makeup. Below is my routine (all products were recommended by my derm except for the cleanser since the original suggestion was discontinued and this routine has been the same since 2020ish).

AM
Cleanser - Alternate between epi.logic True Calm and iS Clinical Cleansing Complex
Exfoliant - ZO Skin Health Exfoliating Polish (3 times a week max)
Toner - Indie Lee Coq10 toner
Treatment - Onexton (clindamycin and benzoyl peroxide)
Moisturizer - the one in question for this post
Sunscreen - EltaMD UV Clear Broad Spectrum SPF 46

PM
Cleanser - same as above but before any liquid cleansers, I use DHC Deep Cleansing Oil
Toner - same
Treatment - Tarzotene .01% (3-4 times a week all over face) and Aquaphor on my under eyes only
Moisturizer - the one in question for this post