r/umineko•
C__J__

Started playing chapter 2

SpoilerDiscussion

I recently started playing umineko, using the patch, and have started playing chapter 2 (i read all the teaparty and the ????).

For the beginning parts of chapter 2, i was clearly under the impression that chapter 2 was adding and filling in the blanks for events in chapter one, with:

  1. George and Shannon prior to the family meeting
  2. Beatrice’s appearance to Shannon and Kanon, and a little bit about Kinzo
  3. The reason Rosa and Maria were late - they went to buy candy after Rosa got mad

I just read up to Beatrice’s appearance before Rosa and Maria, and her restoring the candy.

This clearly conflicted with the events in chapter 1:

Maria and the cousins all went to the guesthouse in chapter 1, and they all went to lunch together.

in chapter 2, Maria stayed in the rose garden until Rosa came back to fetch her (this was when Beatrice appeared), this was before they had lunch.

So then i just wanted to ask (no spoil pls), is chapter 2 actually a “round 2” of Battler vs Beatrice, where the events are resimulated.

If so, can any of the events in chapter 2, specifically those prior to the meeting be applied to chapter 1?
( george and shannon in okinawa, etc)

Maybe im thinking too hard, and its meant to be confusing. 😭😭

Posted Aug 3, 2026, 10:50 AM UTC

27
Loading comments…