Was anyone else told there was a teacher shortage... and then couldn't get a single interview?

I honestly don't know if I just need a reality check or if something else is going on.

I recently completed my master's in education and am certified to teach English Language Arts for grades 7–12 in New York. I've also submitted my CEAS application to transfer my certification to New Jersey. My only classroom experience is student teaching, so I know I'm competing against people with years of experience, but I was constantly told throughout college and grad school that there was a huge teacher shortage and that I'd have no problem finding a job.

Fast forward two months, and I've applied to just about every English/ELA opening I can find in both New York and New Jersey. Public schools, leave replacements, long-term substitute positions, you name it. I've tailored cover letters, updated my resume, and applied almost daily.

The frustrating part is that I'm not even getting rejected. It's just... nothing. No interviews, no emails, no calls. Complete silence.

Is this normal for first-year teachers? Is English just incredibly oversaturated compared to other subjects? Is it because I only have student teaching experience? Or is the hiring season just slower than I expected?

Also, for anyone who transferred their certification from New York to New Jersey through the CEAS reciprocity process, how long did it take for your New Jersey certificate to be issued after you submitted everything? I'm wondering if that timeline is affecting my chances in NJ as well.

I'd love to hear from anyone who was in a similar position, especially if you're in NY or NJ. I'm starting to wonder if I've been given unrealistic expectations about the job market.