[MtF 4M] I took a Magic Potion to Transform into my Crush's Ideal Lover, but I Messed up and became her Dad's Ideal Lover Instead!

NSFW RP - Ongoing

I'd had a crush on Abi since high school, but she had alway been one of the popular crowd and I was a bit of a nerdy wallflower. Fast forward to my early 20s and I found out that she had just moved to the same city as me. I ended up finding out where she lived and went to see if she still looked as great, she obviously did. But I was still the same, and here I was acting like a wannabe stalker.

I resolved to try and forget about her and move on with my life. But I would never forget her.

A month or so later I was out shopping when I spotted a strange shop. I didn't remember it being there before, but it looked like its had been here for years. It was a 'magic' shop. But it wasn't full of magic tricks and stuff like that it seemed to be all about options and spells. Of course magic wasn't real. But I felt compelled to go inside.

Once there I looked around, it was obviously some kind of fake occult shop. But there was an eerie feeling in the air.

"Hello Dan" I heard a voice behind me say and I turned round to see a strange looking old woman.

"How did..." I started to say, "How did you know your name? Magic of course" She said .

"Magic isn't real! Don't be crazy!" I said.

Then she waved her hand in front of me and my t-shirt changed from blue to black. "Are you sure?" I was shocked.

"The magic draws those in need to me, I sense there is something you desire." She said with a mysterious tone.

I don't know why but I felt compelled to tell her all about Abi and my long standing crush, but I knew she would never accept me.

"I can't do anything to her to make her want you, but have something which will change you to be what she wants most in a lover." She told me and a small bottle appeared in her hand and she passed it to me.

"When you drink this potion it will transform you in to the ideal lover of the first person who sees you."

"You mean I'll become the type of guys she's into?" I asked.

"Yes, but be sure this is what you want. There will be no way back to your old life, they will fall in love with you and you with them." She told me.

I was feeling a little skeptical, but I took the potion and paid for it. Then there was a swirling cloud of smoke and I was stood back in the street and where the shop once was was an empty and boarded up shop with a to let sign.

I looked down at the potion and decided to go to her house and knock on the door, if it didn't work I'd just say something like I was at the wrong house or something.

I got on the bus and headed to her house. I looked to see if anyone was in and I saw a car and then a light turn on so she was home.

I stood on the porch and took the bottle. It was now or never I thought and drank it all down. Then I rang the door bell.

I saw the door open and my heart raced, then I saw who had opened it. It wasn't Abi, it was an older guy.

"Erm is Abi home?" I asked

"Oh no she's away I'm her Dad, I'd doing some decorating for her whilst she's on a work trip for a few weeks." He said and then I started to feel an attraction to him building inside me and I saw a funny look in his eyes as he looked at me.

I'm looking for someone to play the Dad character in this RP, I'm thinking he's late 40s to early 50s. He'll be a masculine type of guy.

In terms of how the RP progresses from here I am thinking a gradual transformation over a week or two where I transform into his ideal woman, and I will be he same age as him roughly. The transformation will be both mentally and physically. I'll still have my old memories, but my personality will change, my likes, needs, desires and kinks too.

I imagine that he's not currently married (so divorced or widowed) so there aren't any cheating elements.

I terms of what she is like physically I would prefer a realistic / natural body with all the signs of my new age. But the specifics I am open to us working out together. Same kind of thing with my personality.

I'm open to things like a reality change, where it is as though I've been her all along. For example if he was a widower I could become his late wife and it was as though she'd never died and I take her place, I could be a woman all along in this new world but a new woman he's just met, or even a second wife who he met after he was divorced.

Or we can play is as though it is just me that is changing and we need to make a new identity for me etc.

I do like to work through ideas before we kick off into the role-play so it would be good to know what kind of elements you'd like to include, your kinks and limits as well as your ideas for what you're like and also what the woman I will become will be like.

Kinks: oral, anal, romance, lingerie, age progression, gender change, passionate sex, realistic bodies,

Limits: bathroom stuff, death, violence, incest, BDSM, age gaps between your character and the woman I'll become

Hope to hear from you soon!

Posted Aug 4, 2026, 9:04 AM UTC

11
Loading comments…